[kwlug-disc] how the ^#*&^)(& do i convince debian to install grub, not LILO?

Eric Gerlach eric+kwlug at gerlach.ca
Fri Sep 11 00:00:50 EDT 2009


On Thu, Sep 10, 2009 at 09:42:17AM -0400, Robert P. J. Day wrote:
> On Thu, 10 Sep 2009, Paul Gallaway wrote:
> 
> > >  is this really what a debian install looks for (ext2 vs ext3 for
> > > /boot partition) in deciding whether or not to allow you to use grub?
> >
> > I use ext3 for my '/' (root) partition and have grub installed (and
> > grub2 in one case). I don't have a separate /boot partition so
> > perhaps that makes a difference?
> 
>   from force of habit, i've always created a separate, primary
> partition for my /boot directory, as i like to use LVM for everything
> else.  i did that for a manual install of lenny and chose ext3 for
> /boot (which i thought was perfectly reasonable), but when it came
> time for the bootloader, i was presented with only LILO as a choice.
> 
>   i started the install from scratch and selected the installer to do
> its own pre-defined LVM-based install, and noticed that it also
> created a primary partition for /boot, but only ext2.  so i tried a
> manual install again but choosing ext2 for just that partition, and i
> got grub.
> 
>   i'm concluding that that's what fixed it, because i'm sure i kept
> all the other variables the same.  but if someone wants to test that,
> feel free to correct my thinking.  i just find it odd that a current
> debian install doesn't support a choice of ext3 for that.

Are you using software RAID?  I know I've had issues with GRUB and RAID
in the past, and the Debian installer has played it safe and refused to
install with GRUB.

Cheers,

Eric



More information about the kwlug-disc_kwlug.org mailing list